Be Careful What You Wish For

"You got my cock all messy Larissa," she said, thrusting her hips towards me, "clean it up!" I watched Gina's hand slink around and saw that the redhead was now jacking herself off as she sucked on my asshole. There was nothing for me there. I would need to suck my ass off of Wendy's cock. And I really wanted to. I opened my mouth.

Wendy took a step in closer to me, positioning her hard cock with her hands. I could smell the earthy (but no unpleasant) smell of my ass on her cock. She inched forward again and I felt the tip of Wendy's cock against my lip. I stuck out my tongue and taste my ass and her cock in a delicious combination. Wendy's rolled her head back and moaned. Then she thrust forward, pushing her cock harder into my mouth. Our tastes and smells mixed together in my mouth and nose and made me feel rejuvenated, like I hadn't been fucking all morning. And all the while Gina kept sucking on my ass.

I started to bob my head up and down, working Wendy's cock in and out of my mouth. I heard Gina's hand slapping up and down on her cock and felt her tongue twirling around my anus and poking into my bowels. I decided that if it was good for Gina, it was good for me too and I quickly grasped my cock and started to pump it rhythm with my mouth and Gina's tongue. We were all moving together now, all of us tired, all of us aroused to levels we'd never been before. I heard myself gaggling and I heard Gina gurgling. I tasted my ass and Wendy's cock. It was all too much.

It was as if we all realized it at the same moment, we had all reached some sort of crescendo, our minds, bodies, and souls couldn't take anymore. I felt all of our bodies tense at once. I felt warmth, strength, and weariness slip over my bodies as those all those things were one sensation. I moaned loudly around Wendy's ass-covered she-cock. I heard the others moan as well. And then I felt relaxation pour over me and also extreme, beautiful, sensual exhaustion. And I could taste my mouth filling with Wendy's cum and I could feel my cum and Gina's cum splashing over our bodies as we achieved a mind-bending simultaneous orgasm. The room filled with our smells and our shouts and then, at the same instant, the intensity subsided and we were left, exhausted.

Wendy's cock popped out of my mouth at the same instant that Gina sucked the last of the sperm out of my bowels. Wendy and I collapsed onto the floor, entangled with each other and Gina. The three of us lay panting, trying to catch our breath. I had never felt so relaxed, like I'd converted all of my tension in life into cum and then shot it out in a sea of ecstasy. I looked at the other girls' faces, smiling, and I knew they felt the same way. We relaxed with each other for a long while. Not speaking, just feeling the heat from one another's bodies. Finally, when I felt like I might almost sleep, Gina spoke.

"What the Hell just happened?" Gina asked and we all giggled.

"I don't know," Wendy said, "But it sure as Hell was fun." And we all smiled and agreed. Then, we moved around so that we were lying more comfortably on the floor, holding each other. But suddenly I felt uneasy. 'Hell' was right. And I wondered how all of this would end.

Epilogue: Repayment Due

It was later that night and I was back in my room. The girls and I had eventually cleaned my room (I couldn't believe how much cum there was!) after a long nap and then taken a shower together. We had plans to get back together that night. We'd all felt a little sheepish after our naps (although that didn't stop a little playing in the shower) and we promised we'd talk about it that night. But I knew what 'talking' meant. We were all bound to one another now. We were friends. We were lovers. And it felt good.

But there was someone I really did have to talk to. And I expected she would be there any minute. I was incredibly nervous. I was out of dares and I was now some sort of mutant freak. Beyond that, it seemed that I'd lost any ability to control my sexual impulses (at least around Wendy and Gina). And the worst part of all of it was that I kind of liked it! But I was worried about Lilith. I'd figured out everything else there was to know about her cryptic phone call earlier that morning, but I still didn't know what to think of when she said, "settling."

I was still wearing a bathrobe with nothing under it since the shower, I felt too nervous to unclench my fists, so I couldn't get changed. I was pacing in my room while I waited for her to arrive. I don't know why I knew she'd come, I was out of wishes. But I could tell that there was something left to do. I just didn't know what. My heart was pounding in my chest and my stomach felt watery. I couldn't ever remember being so nervous. I paced to one side of my room, turned around and walked all the way to the other. Then I turned and...ran right into something.

"You girls are nasty!" Lilith said as I stumbled backwards. I'd run right into her large breasts and felt completely disoriented.

"Lilith?" I said, knowing it sounded dumb.

"Who else?" she asked, but she sounded less playful now.

"I didn't do anything you didn't make me do," I said, responding to her initial statement. She shrugged her shoulders disinterestedly.

"I think we are finished with this fight by now, aren't we?" she said.

"I don't think I have any room left to fight," I admitted. She smiled at me.

"So you're done now honey. Time to settle." She got to business quickly.

"What do you mean settle?" I asked, "You said I got to keep my soul until I died."

"True," Lilith said, "As you might have noticed, I say a lot of things. How did all those wishes work out?" She said and then she cackled.

"This isn't fair!" I said, "You've never given me a single thing I wanted without a catch. You have never kept up your end of the deal."

"You got tits, balls, and buddies!" Lilith said, her eyes flashing with fire, "I gave you everything you asked for. I told you to be careful what you wished for. I cannot be held responsible for your recklessness!" she yelled at me. She was standing close to me now, I could feel the heat coming off of her body.

"What then? Do you kill me now and take my soul? That isn't our deal!"

"No, even I won't do that. You are doomed to die eventually anyway. I am patient. More patient than you. I just get to mark you now. That's how we settle. I am going to place my mark on you, so that, if somehow you ever try to slip into the eternal bliss of heaven, they will smell me on you and cast you out!" she laughed and took a step back.

I stood there for a moment, waiting for whatever had come to me. And I knew she was right. I had been reckless. Not just in making my wishes but requesting them in the first place. What had I been thinking? I felt my self-pity, something that had been gone for a couple of days, come back with increased intensity. I felt worthless and alone, everything I had tried to gain from selling my soul and turned to dust and everything I'd tried to run away from was still there.

"Hold still!" Lilith said. But then, I realized something. I hadn't lost my anxiety or my social phobia. I'd gotten some weird things from Lilith, but she hadn't given me what I'd asked for. But, the fact remained, I'd lost my virginity. I'd made friends. And even now, I wanted more of that. Where had that come from if it hadn't been from Lilith? I suddenly felt a different feeling, something uncertain and a little bit scary. But it gave me courage to speak. And to Act. I felt like a different person.

"So Lilith, this was your plan all along wasn't it?" I asked, "You would pretend to give me what I asked for, but it would all be a cruel joke. I wouldn't have anything and you'd turn me into a freak. That's it, isn't it?" I said. Lilith smiled cruelly at me and threw her head back when she laughed.

"I always like it when they figure it out, just at the end!"

"So I was right, this is what you wanted. This is what you wished for?" I said and I untied my robe and threw it off. My swollen breasts and my flaccid cock now exposed. Lilith hooted with delight.

"Exactly what I wanted! It is a work of grotesque art. Now I am going to claim it as my own!" she bellowed. At that instant, her tail whipped around as it had every night for the last three. This time I ducked underneath of it and, as it came whipping back from behind me, I rolled to the side and stuck out of my arm. Rather than smacking against the skin, Lilith's tail wrapped around my arm about seven time like a whip. I then grabbed hold of the tail below that point, jerking her tight.

"Careful what you wish for, bitch!" I screamed at her and then I yanked on her tail as hard as I could. Lilith let out a terrible screech. As I yanked on her tail, Lilith spun around so that her back was to me. She stumbled backwards until she was only a couple inches away from me. I gave a yank up on her tail and it pulled her ass into the air and she bent over at her waist. As she leaned forward, her micro-skirt hiked up and I saw Lilith's red puckered asshole staring up at me. I could also see her red pussy lips. It was incredible, I don't know what I was expecting, but not the normal girl parts in an attractive (if otherworldly red) package. My cock almost instantly sprang to attention, a sort of strange reaction.

"What the fuck do you think your doing?" Lilith cried. I felt her struggle a bit but I yanked hard on her tail and she held still.

"We aren't even yet, you fucked me. Now I get to fuck you!" I said and I shoved Lilith forward. Her skin felt hot on my hands but she slumped forward and caught herself on my bed. I didn't give her time to wriggle. I looked down at her little rosebud of an asshole and knew that is where I wanted to fuck her. I spat on her asshole, trying to lube it up (more for myself than her) but the instant it touched her skin, it turned to steam and sizzled into the air. Lilith cackled.

"You don't have what it takes!" she screeched at me, her face more terrible and beautiful than it had ever appeared before.

"You don't know what I am capable of!" I yelled back. With my free hand, I grabbed my cock at the based and then positioned the purple tip against Lilith's red asshole. Her skin felt hot to the touch. Not scorching, but like skin felt after a long time of tanning. I wondered if I shoved my cock in, if it would melt inside of her. But I didn't care, she was going to pay for a moment.

I tensed my arm and then, in one swift motion, I pulled her sexy little tail back towards me. She hissed loudly, but the positioned of my cock ensure that when she back up, my cock started to pound right into her ass. I felt the tip of my cock pop inside of her. Lilith's asshole easily gave way, opening up to take me in. I felt myself jamming into her, inch by inch. She was hot inside, but not fiery, just a little warmer than Wendy's mouth.

"Oh fuck!" Lilith moaned and I could tell from the way she sounded that it was a mix of pleasure and pain. I slid my cock half out and then yanked on Lilith's tail, slamming it back into the hilt. She squealed. Her voice no longer sounded angry, now it was Lilith's turn to lose control of her body. Now, as I pulled my cock back again, it was Lilith thrusting her hips back, trying to jam the cock in again.

"Fuck me, fuck me!" she begged.

"Beg me by name you fucking whore!" I screamed and with my free hand I slapped her ass hard, a sharp slapping sound echoing through my room.

"Fuck me Larissa! Larissa, I beg you!" she moaned and started to rock my hips quickly. The whole event was so surreal, I couldn't even tell if it were real. Except for the fact that it felt amazing. I'd never so much as fingered my own ass. I had no idea what one felt like inside. But it was amazing, she was so hot and tight inside and I could feel her insides shifting as I thrust into her. I felt my balls tighten, I'd never felt anything so strange and amazing.

I saw Lilith's big tits bouncing as I slammed my cock in and out of her asshole. I reached, again with my free hand, and grabbed the back of her bikini top. I just yanked on it hard and I heard a tear sound. The bikini top came away in my hand and I saw Lilith's big red tits with her perfect black nipples burst free.

"Oh shit!" Lilith moaned and I felt something hot on my bare foot. I looked down and saw clear liquid dripping from Lilith's cunt. With my free hand I reached around Lilith's thigh. Even as I continued to move my cock in and out of her ass, my fingers found her wet pussy. I searched through the folds of her skin and found the hard little nub of her clitoris. The instant I touched it she started to purr. Then, I started to play with it forcefully along the same rhythm as my thrusts. Lilith moaned in ecstasy.

For awhile we fucked. I mean, there is no other way to describe it. It certainly wasn't making love. Lilith's hot, tight asshole sucked on my stiff prick, pulling on it sharply, trying to force me to cum. My fingers danced around Lilith's pussy and I watched her hands as they kneaded her breasts. I could smell the sexual scents of my body (cum, sweat, saliva) mix in the air with her smell of roses and ripened fruit. And the whole time the terrible and beautiful sound of Lilith's moans and groans echoed throughout the room.

"Yes...Yes... Oh fuck yes!" Lilith screamed and I knew she was close. I was pretty close as well. But I had one last little trick in mind. I felt Lilith's body reaching a heightened level of tension. I knew was just second away from coming and, just as she was about to hit the spot, I pulled my cock out of her ass, spun my hand away from her pussy and, in one fluid movement, I spun her around by her tail and released it. Even as I did so I tore off her skirt.

Lilith grunted and seemed to lose her balance. She spun around so that she was facing me and fell onto her knees in front of me. Her big, beautiful breasts bounced on her chest as she fell and her dripping pussy was now fully exposed. I was surprised by how vulnerable she looked naked. Beautiful, but fragile. But I didn't hesitate to think about that and I didn't give her a chance to move.

I stepped forward and grabbed Lilith's horns on either side of her head. My cock ached and I wanted some relief. While Lilith's mouth was still open from screaming in surprise, I shoved my cock, deeply into her mouth. She let out a muffled and surprised cry and her eyes were wide as saucers. I could see some anger in her again, but it was like the dirty taste of my cock mixed with her ass had stunned her into compliance. She started to work my cock into her throat, even though I wasn't even holding her by the tail anymore.

I felt her forked tongue slide up either side of my cock. Her mouth was wet and hot, much hotter than Wendy's. And as she sucked I watched her right hand clutched at her red breast and her left hand stroking her dripping clit. Lilith pulled my cock out of her mouth but continued to lick it, top to bottom, even tonguing my balls. And then she slipped it back into her throat.

All of this was far too intense. The fear and the hatred and the surprising amount of power combined with the sexual thrill of having my cock in someone's mouth and the natural feel of a thick, soft tongue on my balls. It only took a few seconds of her sucking my dick before I was ready to cum. I tightened my grip on Lilith's horns, feeling the tension rising in me. Now I pulled her in hard, shoving my dick as hard down her throat as I could. And just as I felt my balls touch her chin, I felt her body start to shake. She started to moan. Lilith was cumming. And then I tumbled over the edge with her.

I screamed and sort of bounced up and down on my toes. My eyes went blank and the world ceased to exist. It was just me there, and all of the pleasure that my body and my soul was capable of giving me. The vibrations of my muscles gave my entire existence a buzzing feeling and I felt weak and powerful at the same time. It was the most beautifully transcendent moment I'd ever felt. And finally, I felt the hot white jets of my sperm pouring out of my body and splashing into Lilith's mouth.

After a moment, I could sense the world around me again as my orgasm slowly subsided. I looked down and saw Lilith, smiling around my softening cock. Despite the large amount of sperm I tended to produce, Lilith had drank it all down. Just a little white dribble of my jizz was visible on her raven-black lips.

I stood back. Now that I'd cum, I found that my courage had waned a bit. My cock slid out of Lilith's mouth. She was still regally beautiful on her knees. But she rose now, easily. I took a step back. I'd taken a chance. I'd kicked the hornets nest because there was nothing left to do. So I'd got my shot in before I had to pay. Now I was going to pay double. I thought of how wonderful my orgasm had been and had incredible it felt to be powerful. And I stopped backing up. It was worth it.

Lilith stared daggers at me as she moved closer, her beautiful, unworldly body almost gliding towards me. She came with two inches of me and stopped. She looked deeply into my eyes and I could feel her heat and I could sense pure evil pouring out of her. I heard her tail swishing behind her. And then...Lilith laughed. Not her evil, cackling laugh, but an almost joyous sound. Her natural, sultry voice mixed with mirth. It was...weird. I blinked twice.

"You're good!" she said and then she laughed again. I didn't speak, I didn't know what she was thinking, "You are very good."

"Thanks..." I said uneasily, because I couldn't stand the silence.

"I thought I had you completely broken and then you surprise me! And give me a decent fuck to boot. Of course, don't get any funny ideas. I could've stopped that at any second. You surprised me, but you aren't stronger. But you are pretty strong" Then she quickly spun around and walked back towards my bed. My eyes followed her round ass as she moved. When she got to the bed, she turned around and sat. She crossed her legs daintily and leaned forward. She looked like a devil therapist.

"So," she said, "It occurs to me that we made a deal that you would sell your soul to me in exchange for three wishes." She paused like she wanted an answer. She stuck out her tongue and licked the cum off her lips.

"Uh, yeah," I said, still uncertain. I kept waiting for her to attack me. This time, I wouldn't be able to fight her.

"Well, how can one sell something they don't have?" she said, "I mean, not to get too esoteric, but can you sell something that doesn't belong to you? Especially when there is little no chance of acquisition beforehand?"

"No, I guess not," I said, completely unable to discern what she was getting at.

"It seems to me that you sold something to me that you didn't have. When I met you, you didn't have a soul. You were slimy little retch of a thing. Invisible, pathetic, and likely to stay that way. You were already in Hell. You already belonged to me," she said. I wanted to shout back to defend myself, but I didn't know what to say.

"Yeah, I guess so," I finally conceded. She nodded and then looked deeply at me.

"But you certainly have one now. It takes a little soul to do what you did today. And it takes some soul to do what you've done the last three days. Don't get me wrong, it is a dirty little soul. My favorite kind. But it was there," she said. I had no idea what she was getting at.

"Thanks...I think."

"Well then it is agreed," she said.

"What is agreed?"

"Well, I don't have any claim to your soul. You are free to go," she said. My jaw dropped to my chest. What had she just said?

"Huh?"

"Well you can't sell what isn't yours. When we signed the contract, you didn't have a soul. You happened to acquire one now, but that isn't the soul we bargained over. You seemed to have put one over on me. Caveat Emptor I suppose," she said disinterestedly. My mind was reeling, "Of course, you can keep all the 'gifts' I don't want them back." And then, finally, all the pieces fit together. Liltih didn't want my soul! And I could keep my cock and my tits and my friends! And I wanted them all. I couldn't help myself. I ran forward and threw my arms around Lilith.